As San Antonio reels from five hail storms in a single year and Hill Country homeowners discover leaks after historic rains, a recent episode of The Building Texas Show sheds light on a troubling reality: 60 to 70 percent of roof insurance claims are denied. Host Justin McKenzie spoke with Jasper Shin of Texas Roof Guardians at the San Antonio Home and Garden Show about why so many claims fail and what homeowners can do to protect themselves. The conversation is a wake-up call for anyone who assumes their policy will cover storm damage.
Shin, who works directly with homeowners navigating the claims process, points to an incentive structure that often works against policyholders. “The insurance is incentivized to not pay you to say you don't have damage,” he told McKenzie. According to Shin, the average claim file is missing $3,000 to $5,000 in legitimate damages—money that homeowners never see because they don't know how to push back. He describes cases where supplements added $10,000, $15,000, even $30,000 to approved claims, demonstrating the stakes of a well-documented dispute.
The episode details several traps that quietly cost homeowners thousands. Shin explains the full-property inspection that should cover windows, screens, gutters, siding and fences—not just shingles. He highlights the three-reinspection rule most homeowners never learn they have, and the role of Xactimate supplements in forcing fair-market pricing from an adjuster. He also warns about the mortgage-company check split that can stall repairs, and why installing solar on a roof older than seven years is, in his words, asking for leaks.
Perhaps most critical is a single innocent question from a carrier: “Well, why did you wait?” Answer it wrong, Shin explains, and insurers can invoke the mitigation clause buried in most policies and deny the claim for negligence before an adjuster ever climbs a ladder. That warning is especially timely as homeowners in storm-ravaged areas may delay filing while they assess damage or seek contractor advice.
The discussion also tackles the storm-chaser problem plaguing Texas metros from San Antonio and Austin to Dallas and Houston. Shin explains why Texas Roof Guardians chose to stay local rather than chase four-inch hail in Chicago, Montana and the Carolinas, and how homeowners can validate a contractor through GAF, Owens Corning and Atlas certifications, a legitimate Google Business Profile, and Better Business Bureau standing. He shares a Stone Oak case where an insurer quietly converted a client's policy at the 10-year mark, leaving her $15,000 short on a $25,000 replacement—a stark example of why policy reviews matter.
For Texas homeowners, the implications are clear: understanding the claims process before filing can mean the difference between a denied claim and a fully funded repair. The episode, available on The Building Texas Show, offers practical guidance on free policy reviews, biannual inspections, and how to spot red flags in a contractor. As severe weather continues to batter the state, that knowledge may be the most valuable tool a homeowner has.


