For years, ranking No. 1 on Google was the ultimate goal of search engine optimization. But a 2025 analysis suggests that being the top organic result no longer guarantees visibility, as AI Overviews, ads, and local Map Pack results increasingly push traditional listings below the fold. The analysis, conducted by GrowthSRC Media and reported by Search Engine Journal, examined more than 200,000 keywords across 30 websites and found that the click-through rate for the top organic result fell from 28% to 19% after AI Overviews expanded.
The finding challenges a core assumption of many SEO strategies: that a high ranking automatically translates into customer traffic. According to the analysis, the correlation between the expansion of AI Overviews and the decline in click-through rates does not prove causation, but it raises important questions about what customers actually see when they search. “Business owners can still be proud of ranking number one,” said David Brown, founder of db Consulting. “But they should also ask what customers see before that listing. If an AI answer, ads and a Map Pack fill the screen first, the ranking report may tell only part of the story.”
The implication is clear: businesses need to broaden their visibility strategy beyond traditional rankings. Brown advises companies to search for the service they most want to sell in the city they most want to reach, using a phone, and to check where their business appears in Maps, AI-generated answers, and traditional listings. “This isn’t the end of SEO,” Brown said. “It’s the end of pretending one position number tells you whether customers can find you. Customers see the whole page, from AI answers and Maps to traditional listings. Your strategy has to reflect what they actually see.”
For local businesses, the stakes are high. If customers are ready to choose a service but cannot see a business because it is buried beneath other elements, the business may lose the opportunity entirely. Brown’s firm, db Consulting, works with clients on local search, Google Maps visibility, AI search presence, and digital PR, often in partnership with Newsworthy.ai and Encino Labs. The firm offers a free visibility review through neo1seo.com, where businesses can see where they appear across Google Maps, AI-powered results, and traditional listings.
Brown’s perspective is pragmatic rather than alarmist. Asked whether business owners should panic, he offered a lighthearted analogy: “My cat Batman doesn’t understand Google’s algorithm. He just steps in front of my screen until I notice him. Honestly, that’s a better visibility strategy than hoping someone scrolls down.” The message is that businesses must adapt to the evolving search landscape, where visibility is no longer just about ranking first but about being present wherever customers look.


