Pre-Existing Back Injury Doesn't Bar $1.6M Settlement in Manchester Road Crash

A $1.6 million settlement in St. Louis County shows how medical causation evidence can overcome a prior injury defense and secure compensation for a client who needed three-level spine surgery after a Des Peres collision.

Chicago Metrowire Staff
••Legal
Pre-Existing Back Injury Doesn't Bar $1.6M Settlement in Manchester Road Crash

A $1.6 million settlement secured by Brown & Crouppen on behalf of a client injured in a Des Peres, Missouri, motor vehicle collision underscores the critical role medical causation evidence plays when a defendant argues that a plaintiff's pre-existing condition is to blame. The case, led by attorney Rich Zalasky, resolved on August 31, 2026, in St. Louis County.

The crash occurred on Manchester Road east of Interstate 270, where the defendant turned left out of the center turn lane directly into the client's path, leaving her no opportunity to avoid impact. The collision caused severe lower-back injuries requiring a three-level spine surgery involving two disc replacements and a spinal fusion. Because the client had a documented history of lower-back problems before the crash, the defense centered its strategy on that history, contending the collision was not responsible for the surgery she ultimately needed.

Zalasky and his team focused their argument on medical causation. The central question was not whether the client had experienced back trouble before the collision, but whether the collision transformed a manageable condition into a disabling one. The medical evidence supported the latter conclusion. As the case moved toward trial, the parties entered mediation, and a settlement was reached the following week.

Insurance companies frequently cite a plaintiff's prior medical history to reduce the perceived value of a claim. A documented medical connection between the collision and the resulting injury is what counters that position. "Insurance companies look for a reason to pay less, and a prior injury is one of the easiest ones to reach for," said Andy Crouppen, Managing Partner of Brown & Crouppen. "Someone who has had back trouble before still deserves to be made whole when a crash makes it worse. Rich and his team proved that connection with medical evidence, and they were ready to take it to trial. That is what moved this one."

The implications of this settlement extend beyond the individual case. It reinforces that a pre-existing condition does not automatically bar recovery in personal injury claims, provided that medical evidence can establish a causal link between the accident and the aggravation of that condition. For plaintiffs with prior injuries, the outcome highlights the importance of retaining counsel capable of presenting persuasive medical testimony and prepared to proceed to trial if necessary. The settlement also contributes to the more than $2 billion Brown & Crouppen has recovered for clients since the firm was founded in 1979.

Past results afford no guarantee of future results. Every case is different and must be judged on its own merits.

Blockchain Registration

QR Code for Blockchain Registration